Shane Bieber strolled back in from the bullpen on Monday at PNC Park, offering head nods and fist bumps to a handful of teammates and Blue Jays staff members on his way to the dugout.
On the surface, it was a familiar pregame scene, one featuring a veteran starting pitcher going about his business, completing the necessary work in the days between outings to ensure he’s prepared to compete at the highest level. But for Bieber, who is still getting used to his new threads after being acquired by Toronto from the only organization he’d ever known in Cleveland, these seemingly banal moments carry notably more weight.
Monday’s session was a final tune-up for a day he’s been working toward for quite some time. ]
Without the ability to overwhelm opponents with pure power, Bieber deftly deploys his four-seamer around the zone to set up his two primary whiff-inducing weapons, a low-80s knuckle-curve and a sharp, mid-80s slider. Add a cutter and a change-up to assist in neutralizing left-handed batters, and Bieber wields a deep array of offerings that makes for an ultra-uncomfortable at-bat.
“He gave us fits from the other side, always a tough matchup for us,” Blue Jays pitching coach Pete Walker said. “He’s got tremendous stuff, he’s got a repeatable delivery, he executes his fastball and his breaking stuff with the best of them. Very cerebral, smart pitcher who recognizes swings and has a good game plan. And I think you recognize that right away when you watch him pitch.”
Bieber has yet to throw an inning for the Blue Jays, but Toronto’s coaching staff has already gained a deeper appreciation for the pitcher and the person.
“I’ve admired him from afar for a number of years,” Schneider said. “And just in talking to him, you can see why he is as accomplished as he is.”
“He’s got an easy personality, an easy way about him. He’s an intellect, but he also finds a way to keep things simple,” Walker said. “He’s thrown some really good bullpens here. We’ve watched all of his rehab games. He’s executing his pitches well. He just carries himself like a pro.
“And you know when you watch him pitch, even in Triple-A, he looks like an elite big leaguer.”
‘These guys, they’re animals’
Beginning Friday, Bieber joins a Blue Jays rotation that is in an interesting spot. It’s a unit with five established and (currently) healthy hurlers but also one that ranks 20th in ERA and 27th in fWAR on the season. It’s a group that includes four accomplished right-handers in Kevin Gausman, Chris Bassitt, Jose Berrios and Max Scherzer, plus a surprise contributor in lefty Eric Lauer. For as effective as he has been since joining the rotation in mid-June (3.05 ERA in 62 innings across 12 starts), Lauer appears to be the most obvious candidate to return to his prior role as a swingman, but the Blue Jays insist that roles could be fluid in the coming weeks as the team figures out the best way to accommodate Bieber’s schedule while covering as many innings as possible.
However the rotation shakes out over the next few weeks — and, even more intriguingly, once October arrives — Bieber is eager to give his new team a boost, albeit in a different role than the one he filled with the Guardians. In Cleveland, Bieber had comfortably achieved veteran status — “old and salty,” he joked — and would’ve been rejoining the starting staff as the most senior member at the age of 30. Instead, with the Blue Jays, not only will Bieber be the new guy, but he’ll also be the young gun of sorts, even as his return marks his eighth major-league season. Berrios (31, 10th season), Gausman (34, 13th), Bassitt (36, 11th) and Scherzer (41, 18th) have combined to pitch 7,608 ⅓ innings across 1,265 regular-season starts in their careers. It’s an astonishing wealth of experience to draw upon and share, an advantage that is not lost on Bieber.
“It’s fantastic,” he said. “I’ve had the pleasure of competing against them from the other dugout, so now I get the privilege of getting to know them as teammates and friends. And then also on top of that, just picking their brains on how they like to do things. … I’m eager to ask questions and learn from them as much as I can.”
It’s a dynamic that Toronto’s coaching staff has seen manifest in positive ways even before Bieber’s arrival.
“When it comes together like that and you got some of the names that we have right now, and the experience, it’s a luxury,” Walker said.
“We’ve got different personalities … but the one variable that’s the same is, between the lines, these guys, they’re animals,” he continued. “It’s very competitive, a controlled aggression. … They’re coming after you. And that rubs off on the teammates. Max [Scherzer], in a way, has rubbed off on his teammates in that aspect. And we expect Shane to do the same.”
Beyond the staggering track record of pitching at the highest level, there’s an ambitious mentality that separates this group even after all the years — and that’s a trait that Bieber clearly exhibits.
“Sometimes guys can be around a long time and lose a little bit, or become a little complacent. This group has zero complacency,” Walker said. “And you can tell they’ve all turned it up a notch. In a way, it’s a healthy competition. They want to pick each other up. They want to pitch just as well the next time out as the previous starter. And I think that’s contagious, and it’s very healthy.”
‘He’s looking forward to Friday as much as we are’
Yet for all the justified excitement about Bieber joining the fold, it’s quite possible this will be a temporary partnership. If he pitches well down the stretch, it seems likely he’ll opt out of the $16 million he’s slated to make in 2026, becoming a free agent for the second winter in a row; a fully healthy Bieber would surely secure a more lucrative deal on the open market. On the other side, the Blue Jays’ aging rotation faces some long-term questions, with Bassitt and Scherzer both also set to hit free agency.
But regardless of the duration of Bieber’s run as a Blue Jay, what matters is the here and now. Friday at loanDepot Park marks the first step in his personal quest to regain ace status and the first opportunity for him to make an impact for a team that bet big on his resurgence in the thick of a pennant race.
“He’s been chomping at the bit,” Schneider said of his new starter. “Pitchers know how they feel, and I think especially pitchers of his caliber, they know what their stuff is doing. So he’s excited, and I think that he’s looking forward to Friday as much as we are.
“It’s a long road to get back from that injury — days at the complex, minor-league game after minor-league game on such a strict schedule. He’s enjoyed just being in the dugout and being part of it now, not even pitching. I’m sure getting back on a big-league mound will be good for him.”
As his return to a big-league mound has neared, Bieber’s confidence has only increased. But he fully understands the challenge that lies ahead — and that looking sharp in rehab outings can tell you only so much.
“As great as being built up to 90 pitches in the minor leagues is,” he said, “big-league innings are different.
“So it’s exciting to be able to experience that here soon.”